U SPORTS Bronze Medals (since 1980)
1988-89 
 
U SPORTS Rookie of the Year
2014-15 – Josh Henderson
 
U SPORTS First-Team All-Canadians (since 1981)
2016-17 – Alex Duncan-Thibault
2014-15 – Ray Szeto
2012-13 – Ray Szeto
1988-89 – Bill Knight
 
U SPORTS Second-Team All-Canadians (since 1981)
2024-25 – Dennis Cota
2015-16 – Arthur Szwarc
2013-14 – Ray Szeto
2003-04 – Darren Goss
2002-03 – Mingo Miguel
1997-98 – Richard Van Huizen
1993-94 – Dexter Abrams
1989-90 – Dexter Abrams
1988-89 – Dexter Abrams
1983-84 – Dave Samek
1981-82 – Dave Chambers
 
U SPORTS All-Rookie Team
2024-25 – Chris Hoffman
2014-15 – Josh Henderson
2013-14 – Nicolas Pirnat
   
OUA Championship Titles (since 1965)
2004-05, 1993-94, 1992-93, 1988-89, 1981-82, 1980-81, 1979-80, 1973-74, 1972-73
 
OUA Bronze Medals
2014-15
 
OUA East Most Valuable Player (since 2004)
2016-17 – Alex Duncan-Thibault
 
OUA Libero of the Year (since 2004)
2006-07 – Rob Dyba
 
OUA Rookie of the Year (since 1996)
2024-25 – Chris Hoffman
2014-15 – Josh Henderson
1999-00 – Simon Van Bommel
 
OUA East Dale Iwanoczko Sportsman Award (since 1995)
2021-22 – Dan Everton
2017-18 – Spencer Dakin Kuiper
2016-17 – Alex Duncan-Thibault
2013-14 – Greg Ivan
2011-12 – Karim Khalil
2002-03 – Mingo Miguel
 
OUA Coach of the Year (since 1996)
2016-17 – Michael Wahbi
1997-98 – Wally Dyba 
1996-97 – Wally Dyba 
 
OUA First Team All-Stars (since 1977)
2024-25 – Dennis Cota
2022-23 – Josh Fadare, Andrew Tauhid
2021-22 – Andrew Tauhid
2018-19 – Logan Mend
2017-18 – Logan Mend, Andrew Shotbolt
2016-17 – Alex Duncan-Thibault, Logan Mend
2015-16 – Arthur Szwarc
2014-15 – Ray Szeto
2013-14 – Ray Szeto
2012-13 – Ray Szeto
2006-07 – Ryan Anderson
2004-05 – Ryan Anderson, Jason Kinoshita
2003-04 – Darren Goss, Ryan Anderson
2002-03 – Mingo Miguel
2001-02 – Ben Smyth
2000-01 – Mingo Miguel
1998-99 – Paul Costantinou, Duane Lunn
1997-98 – Joel Jansen, Richard Van Huizen
1996-97 – Joe Kupina, Richard Van Huizen
1995-96 – Djordje Ljubicic, Richard Van Huizen
1994-95 – Djordje Ljubicic, Glen Smith
1993-94 – Dexter Abrams, Djordje Ljubicic
1992-93 – Dexter Abrams, Djordje Ljubicic, Glen Smith
1991-92 – Adrian Adore, Djordje Ljubicic
1990-91 – Dexter Abrams, Adrian Adore
1989-90 – Dexter Abrams, Adrian Adore
1988-89 – Dexter Abrams, Bill Knight, Jacob Wiktorek
1987-88 – Bruce Dunning
1986-87 – Tony Martino
1985-86 – Alex Ketrvynsky, Dave Samek, John Spicker
1984-85 – Steve Burtch, Dave Samek
1983-84 – Dave Samek, Walter Zanel
1982-83 – Steve Burtch, Dave Chambers, John May
1981-82 – Mark Ainsworth, Dave Chambers, John May, Dave Samek
1980-81 – Mark Ainsworth, Dave Chambers
1979-80 – Mark Ainsworth, Dave Chambers, Lino Girardo
1978-79 – Mark Ainsworth
 
OUA Second Team All-Stars (since 1995)
2023-24 – Dennis Cota, Jasraj Nijjar
2022-23 – Jasraj Nijar
2019-20 – Andrew Shotbolt
2018-19 – Andrew Tauhid
2016-17 – Toure Nwakwesi
2014-15 – Josh Henderson
2013-14 – Greg Ivan
2012-13 – Felipe Humana-Paredes
2008-09 – Reid Hall
2007-08 – Reid Hall
2006-07 – Paul Podstawka
2005-06 – Ryan Anderson, Sholan Trivedi
2003-04 – Daniel Bache
2002-03 – Darren Goss
2001-02 – Darren Goss, Mingo Miguel
2000-01 – Darren Goss, Jamal Thomas
1999-00 – Duane Lunn, Simon Van Bommel
1997-98 – Paul Constantinou, Steve Mackey, Andrew Sulatycki
1995-96 – Joe Kupina

OUA Third Team All-Stars (since 2024)
2024-25 – Alex Dorling
 
OUA All-Rookie Team (since 2004)
2024-25 – Chris Hoffman
2022-23 – Dennis Cota
2021-22 – Jasraj Nijjar
2019-20 – Luke de Greeff
2018-19 – Dan Everton
2017-18 – Andrew Tauhid
2014-15 – Josh Henderson
2013-14 – Nicolas Pirnat
2011-12 – Marko Dakic
2010-11 – Ray Szeto
2009-10 – Marvin Macalino
2007-08 – Tom Podstawka
2005-06 – Adam Podstawka
2004-05 – Paul Podstawka, Sholan Trivedi
   
York Athlete of the Year (since 1968)
1992-93 – Dexter Abrams
 
Outstanding Men's Graduate Award (since 2015)
2021-22 – Dan Everton
2017-18 – Tim Jensen
 
Lions Legacy Awards (since 2015)
2021-22 – Dan Everton
2017-18 – Tim Jensen
 
Charles Saundercook Memorial Trophy (since 1978)
2001-02 – Mingo Miguel
1991-92 – James Dalziel
1978-79 – Larry Simpson
 
York Rookie of the Year (since 2000)
2021-22 – Jasraj Nijjar
2017-18 – Andrew Tauhid
2014-15 – Josh Henderson
 
Hall of Fame Inductee (since 1980)
2019 – David Samek
2015 – Djordje Ljubicic
2011 – Dexter Abrams
2008 – John May
2005 – Mark Ainsworth
2002 – Dave Chambers

York Coach of the Year (since 2011)
2024-25 – Jordan Taylor
 
Team MVPs
2024-25 – Dennis Cota
2023-24 – Dennis Cota
2022-23 – Andrew Tauhid
2021-22 – Andrew Tauhid
2020-21 – Not Awarded (COVID-19 Pandemic)
2019-20 – Andrew Shotbolt
2018-19 – Logan Mend
2017-18 – Logan Mend
2016-17 – Alex Duncan-Thibault
2015-16 – Arthur Szwarc
2014-15 – Ray Szeto
2013-14 – Ray Szeto
2012-13 – Ray Szeto
2011-12 – Greg Ivan
2010-11 – Karim Khalil
2009-10 – Reid Hall
2008-09 – Reid Hall
2007-08 – Reid Hall
2006-07 – Ryan Anderson
2005-06 – James Battiston
2004-05 – Ryan Anderson
2003-04 – Darren Goss
2002-03 – Domingo Miguel
2001-02 – Domingo Miguel
2000-01 – Domingo Miguel